This website uses cookies

Read our Privacy policy and Terms of use for more information.

For at least the last five years, federal permitting reform has moved in fits and starts. Round after round of legislative proposals have been developed but never passed. Reforms coming out of the executive branch were mostly reversed between the first Trump, Biden and second Trump administrations. Even the permitting reforms included in the Fiscal Responsibility Act, which passed in 2023, were relatively modest administrative reforms. The draft Bipartisan American Affordability and Jobs Act (BAAJA) unveiled by the Senate at the end of September is still not law, and it will face quite a political fight to become law after the midterms. At this point, no one would be faulted for waiting to see if the BAAJA actually becomes law before digging into the details.

But the BAAJA is not like the permitting reform legislation that has come before it. If it does pass into law, it would be the most substantial federal permitting reform bill since the early 1970s. And it would, in my estimation, actually work. Federal permitting would be more certain and federal agencies would have more discretion when completing environmental studies of projects if BAAJA becomes law. The most important changes, by far, are limitations on the use of injunction remedies by federal courts when responding to claims under the National Environmental Policy Act (NEPA), but the use of injunctions is also curtailed under the National Historic Preservation Act (NHPA) and Section 404 of the Clean Water Act (CWA), among other changes.

There are many, many other changes to federal permitting and development authorities in the draft BAAJA. Energy sector development would see the biggest changes. Backstop authority for the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission (FERC) to permit new transmission lines would be significantly enhanced. Geothermal projects in particular would have new statutory categorical exclusions from NEPA and other permit streamlining. The ability of states to block projects using the CWA section 401 process is also significantly curtailed, which will especially improve development certainty for transmission lines, pipelines and other linear projects. It appears that the law would improve the development economics of most infrastructure sectors save one: datacenters. And even for datacenter development, many of the changes impacting the sector are related to energy costs and interconnection queues, as opposed to a new federal procedural requirement for the recently-maligned projects.

The purpose of this article, however, is to examine some of the specific ways that BAAJA could change the P3 industry in the United States. And even if the BAAJA never makes it out of the Senate, then the myriad reforms included in BAAJA will likely be the starting point for the next time Congress takes up permitting reform. In other words, the mere fact that the draft language of BAAJA exists is a major step towards true permitting reform in the United States, even if the legislation doesn’t survive the midterms.

Alternative Technical Permits

BAAJA’s supporters and opponents appear to agree on one thing: the curtailment of injunctive relief for NEPA rulings is the most important change that the new legislation would make. In the future, when a federal judge finds an environmental study for an infrastructure project to be insufficient, they may remand the study back to the federal agency for additional study, with a 180 day deadline. However, that judge would no longer be able to enjoin the project while the environmental study is being updated.

See Related PWF Articles

logo

Subscribe for full access.

Become a paying subscriber to get access to this article and the rest of PWF's online article archive.

Upgrade

Subscribers receive:

  • Future PWF subscriber-only articles.
  • Full access to our online commentary and news coverage.
  • Access to PWF's online article archive.