This website uses cookies

Read our Privacy policy and Terms of use for more information.

A growing trend in long-term P3s for express toll lanes procurement is inclusion of a multi-billion-dollar concession fee that bidders now seem compelled to include in their proposals. If three teams are short-listed, with comparable P3 express toll lane experience, the state DOT seems likely to select the one offering the largest concession fee.

Traditionally, up-front concession fees have been standard practice in brownfield concessions, where it’s considered the price of admission to the short list of qualified bidders. But this year, concession fees are showing up in winning proposals for greenfield express toll lane projects carried out as long-term DBFOM concessions.

Since this trend got started, it seems to have become a requirement to be selected as a qualified P3 team for express toll lane projects. Two prominent examples are I-24 in Tennessee and I-285 in Georgia, with concession fees from the winning teams of $24.8 billion and $23.6 billion, respectively.

For state DOTs, multi-billion-dollar concession fees are free money, for which they can readily find productive uses, including (as GDOT points out), to improve roads that connect to the express toll lane project.

My questions, however, are about who ends up bearing the cost of these multi-billion-dollar concession fees. Some of the recent commentary on this subject suggests that the long-term value of the concession somehow makes it a wise expenditure for the concession company.

See Related PWF Articles

logo

Subscribe for full access.

Become a paying subscriber to get access to this article and the rest of PWF's online article archive.

Upgrade

Already a subscriber? Sign in

Subscribers receive:

  • Future PWF subscriber-only articles.
  • Full access to our online commentary and news coverage.
  • Access to PWF's online article archive.